Navy Airman Jumps Overboard, Gets Discharged for Not Dying Properly
Navy airman Nicholas McKelvey jumped off the USS Abraham Lincoln after 255 days of grueling deployment, only to be discharged for faking a mental health crisis - because wearing a float coat means you weren't really trying.
In a move that surprises absolutely no one familiar with military bureaucracy, the U.S. Navy has decided that the appropriate response to a 19-year-old sailor jumping off an aircraft carrier in distress is to punish him for it. Nicholas McKelvey, a Navy airman, leapt into the Arabian Sea on Aug. 3 - 255 days into the USS Abraham Lincoln's deployment - after working 12-hour shifts in extreme heat with limited food, missing the birth of his daughter, and dealing with in-laws battling cancer. He was rescued by a helicopter crew 50 minutes later, because apparently even a suicide attempt requires a rescue mission that the Navy can later use against you.
According to U.S. Navy records reviewed by The New York Times, an officer acknowledged it had been "a difficult deployment" and that "it is unsurprising that we might have a jumper." But the same report also noted McKelvey's "motives are undetermined" and "the conditions in which he jumped appear suspect," pointing to the fact that he wore his "float coat" - a vest that can be used as a flotation device. Because clearly, if you're going to end it all, you should do so without any safety equipment, lest your survival be seen as premeditated.
McKelvey, for his part, offered a remarkably lucid explanation to the Times: "I didn't want to be there anymore. If I was going to die because of it, then that's just how it is." He added, "Obviously, I was trying to get home. I kept my float coat on because if I wasn't supposed to die then I was going to get saved, but it didn't matter, and if I was supposed to die then I would have just been dead. It's that simple." It's the kind of fatalistic logic that makes you wonder why the Navy didn't just give him a medal for clarity.
The Navy on Thursday moved to discharge McKelvey, accusing him of faking a mental health crisis to end his deployment - a charge that conveniently makes him ineligible for education assistance under the GI Bill of Rights. The Lincoln, which docked in San Diego this month after a 322-day deployment that was extended as part of the war against Iran, had been helping enforce the U.S. naval blockade in the region. The deployment has come under intense scrutiny due to tight food supplies and degrading mental health on board. The ship didn't have a port call for 286 days until it finally docked in Thailand last month for a short period. Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao later revealed there had been eight suicide attempts during the lengthy deployment - a statistic that the Navy apparently prefers to address by punishing the survivors.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has conceded the Lincoln's crew members operated in a tough environment but accused the news media of attempting to "turn the USS Abraham Lincoln into some sort of a symbol of dysfunction or a symbol of low morale, or a symbol of a failed mission." Because nothing says "mission success" like eight suicide attempts and a 19-year-old jumping overboard.
McKelvey and his wife, Samantha Larry, said they are speaking out now because they believe he received inadequate mental health care before and after his jump, making his punishment unfair. The sailor said in June that he visited the ship's medical unit for mental health care but was directed to speak with a chaplain - a choice he declined, according to the Times. The Lincoln only had six mental health specialists for a ship of more than 5,000 service members, which is roughly the same ratio as a single therapist at a music festival.
"They don't want to take accountability for what happened to him, and to what happened to multiple sailors on the boat," Larry said. "I don't think that they care." She added, "They care more about how they're pictured, how they're viewed. They don't want anyone to see the bad stuff." The Navy charged McKelvey with malingering and "absence without leave" for abandoning his post when he jumped, according to charging papers reviewed by the outlet. Because in the Navy, attempting suicide is apparently just going AWOL with extra steps.
The Good Times
News in your inbox.
One sardonic roundup, delivered on your schedule. Free. Unsubscribe whenever your tolerance for wit runs out.
Already subscribed but we never reach your inbox? Check your spam folder and hit 'Not spam' (or 'Remove from spam') to bust us out of junk-mail purgatory. You'll be helping everyone else too.
Don't open any of our emails for a month and you'll be automatically removed from the mailing list.
Rewrite Article
Select parts to regenerate with a fresh AI pass. Translations will be updated automatically.
Generate AI Image
Creates a sardonic version of the article image using OpenAI.