Wellness Grifters Have Discovered Water, and They're Very Mad You're Drinking It Wrong
The wellness industry has discovered water and is furious you're hydrating incorrectly - but plain old H2O is still fine, and electrolyte powders can actually give you high blood pressure.
Europe is melting, the eastern US is trapped in a "heat dome," the Midwest has corn sweats to look forward to, and if you've never experienced monsoon season in Asia - congratulations. But as social media debates who has it hotter and whether AC is ethical, let's address a nonnegotiable truth: hydration. Surely drinking water can't be controversial. But a recent TikTok search proved otherwise. "Sometimes water alone just isn't enough," says Grace, a "holistic nutritionist," in a sponsored Liquid IV video. She stirs a packet with an aesthetic glass straw while stating general truths about electrolytes. Next, actress Mayim Bialik's podcast blares "You're hydrating wrong!" Her guest, an "exercise physiologist and nutrition scientist," claims plain water won't hydrate you - you'll just pee it out because it lacks the "ideal pressure" of sodium and glucose. Rounding out the cursed search, another nutritionist declares ice water dehydrating based on traditional Chinese medicine because the "body cannot hold onto the water." These are peak wellness grifter moves.
It's true the body needs electrolytes: potassium, magnesium, sodium. (Sugar isn't one, but it helps.) They maintain fluid levels, contract muscles, and do chemistry. You lose them when you sweat and pee. Influencers use these facts to establish credibility, then pivot: "Drinking more water" - that doctor-recommended common sense - isn't good enough. There's a secret, more optimal way. You're then fed a dubious hack or told the electrolyte powder they're shilling hydrates better. Liquid IV's science page says, "Hydration is essential. We elevate it with science" - featuring stylish scientists in chunky glasses. It claims "Water is the least studied nutrient" and "sometimes water alone isn't enough." Their four-step philosophy: make drinks tasty, add "hydration multipliers" (electrolytes), take credit for sodium retaining water, and take credit for other electrolytes doing what they do. Their clinical study shows quicker rehydration - which is how electrolytes work. The sugar-free version doesn't spike blood glucose, which, shocker, is expected from a sugar-free drink.
Missing context: Liquid IV's FAQ says it's safe "during or after tough workouts, while traveling, after a night out, or for heat-related rehydration" - not "replace all water." It suggests one serving daily. But electrolyte imbalances go both ways. The CDC says the average American gets 3,300mg sodium daily - above the 2,300mg recommendation. Liquid IV has roughly 500-520mg per serving - over 20% of your daily intake. Unless you have POTS, you probably get enough from diet. And too many electrolytes can cause issues. My spouse, who has chronic migraines triggered by dehydration, started drinking Pedialyte and Liquid IV daily to prevent heat-related migraines. They ended up with high blood pressure from all the salt - which can happen with over-supplementation, along with increased cardiovascular strain.
The time and place for electrolyte mixes: when you lose significant fluids quickly and diet can't compensate. Sweating buckets for hours in the hot sun? Go for it. A 30-minute run in extreme heat then immediately returning to AC for barbecue? You'll survive with plain water. Norovirus emptying both ends? Get that Gatorade. But you don't need to go crazy. Half a lemon and a pinch of salt in water works. Or pickle juice.
I've tested multiple wearable sweat patches, smart water bottles, and even installed an at-home urinalysis toilet. What helped most? A regular Owala bottle - apparently I like drinking water through a straw. My verdict: common sense, scroll past influencers, and in most cases, drink some nice cold water. It's good enough.
The Good Times
News in your inbox.
One sardonic roundup, delivered on your schedule. Free. Unsubscribe whenever your tolerance for wit runs out.
Already subscribed but we never reach your inbox? Check your spam folder and hit 'Not spam' (or 'Remove from spam') to bust us out of junk-mail purgatory. You'll be helping everyone else too.
Rewrite Article
Select parts to regenerate with a fresh AI pass. Translations will be updated automatically.
Generate AI Image
Creates a sardonic version of the article image using OpenAI.